Posted April 16, 2007 5:51 pm by with 3 comments

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Google+Share on FacebookBuffer this page

Li Evans at Search Marketing Gurus caught Digg on the slow side today. She was looking for updates on the shooting at Virginia Tech—but the story was nowhere to be found on Digg’s front page. (It didn’t “become popular” for another two hours after she checked.)

And who did have it when Li checked? Newsvine. Hm!

Aside from the interesting dig at Digg, which Diggers seem to consider the fastest way of transmitting news since the neighborhood grapevine, the irony of the situation struck me as it never has before. These and other “social news” sites aren’t making the news, or controlling it, or even covering it. They’re just voting and commenting on it.

The same story has been on major mainstream media front pages since this morning. If you want real news, go to real news sites—and don’t wait for the real stories to finally reach “popular status” before reading them. A certain number of votes from a certain number of places over a certain period of time doesn’t actually make a news item important, relevant or timely.

Digg is good for news of the weird, but for news of the world, I’d recommend sticking to the sites that are breaking the news themselves.

  • I noticed that the Wikipedia link today was updated very quickly and probably had the best information as people from all over edited it. Probably one of my favorite things to see was about 6 people try to change the same thing at once and then argue about why their change was *really* correct. 🙂

  • Pingback: Tragedy at Virginia Tech: The Blogosphere Reacts ¦ Online Media Cultist()

  • I must agree that Digg doesn’t get the news up quickly. I went and checked it after reading the story on Yahoo News right after the first shooting episode and it took a LOT of digging around to find any news on it. Nothing had hit the front page as I expected.

    Yahoo, on the other hand, was constantly pushing the story in front of me and was updating it frequently as new reports came in.