Google vs. Microsoft – Who’s the Bad Guy?



A recent article here on MarketingPilgrim, which referred to an interview with Eric Schmidt, where he basically saw Microsoft as the “evil” company the knight in shining armor (since Google’s CEO was being interviewed, I’m sure it’s clear who he sees as the “knight in shining armor”) needs to protect us from gave me the idea for today’s post

Obviously, the opinion in question is anything but objective, but it does make us wonder: who exactly is the bad guy? Given the fact that Google and Microsoft don’t exactly have a stainless track record, it’s definitely hard to tell.

On the one hand, we have Google as the biggest player in search, a company which is basically dominating the Web and, as a result, it should come as no surprise that most folks see this as something extremely dangerous. The fact that they are also in quite a shopping spree also contributes to the “bad guy” image Google has.

On the other hand, there’s Microsoft and I believe the name says it all. It’s definitely safe to assume that Microsoft is not exactly the most popular company and, naturally, their previous interest in Yahoo! is seen by many as an attempt to try and dominate the Web as well, as an attempt to crush a company which, as far as search is concerned, seems to be following in their footsteps when it comes to “domination” (once again, the word “Windows” says it all).

All in all, two big players are competing for an extremely important piece of the Internet pie: Yahoo! (note: MSFT has now withdrawn its bid) . Even more so, it seems that both of them are as hungry as it gets and, as funny as it may sound, both of them are actually trying to convince us that they are here to “save us”.

Will Google save us from Microsoft? Will Microsoft save us from Google? You can’t be serious! The image of an Internet user who believes that one of these two companies is here to save him or her is similar to that of a fish who expects to be saved by one of the two fishermen who have just arrived at the lake.

Let’s keep our feet on the ground, shall we? Google or Microsoft, who is the bad guy? It would be harsh to label any of the two companies as “bad guys”, but one thing is clear: none of them are knights in shining armor.

Best wishes,

Alan Johnson

  • http://www.weightlossinfo.us/blog tony dee

    In my own opinion, Google get’s the razzie award for all of it’s strict compliance rules. Why smash a little guy like myself because people want their products and services given maximum exposure?

  • http://chasinggoogle.blogspot.com/ Elections guy

    Please save me from MS passport.net crap.

    Elections guy’s last blog post..Polls before Pennsylvania primary: Obama most popular

  • http://www.marketingpilgrim.com Andy Beal

    @Elections guy – I agree, but then again we’re all happy to sign-up for a Google Account–which is the same as Passport, no?

  • http://www.talkaboutnet.com Webmaster Forums

    @Andy Beal – It’s same yes, but interfaces are different.. Any you can hack a msn account very easily.

  • http://yourgreatestgifts.co.uk wii guy

    Neither are particularly bad guys. They are both trying to make as much money as possible no matter how well they try and describe it. Microsft dominating the software sector is as bad as Google dominating the internet. People use Google because it’s the best out there so why should they be attacked because of the great service they use. There is also a reason Microsoft grew so big.

    Neither are bad guys. They both just want money..

    John

  • http://www.weightlossinfo.us tony dee

    Wii guy, you are right, it’s all about the bottom line. However when do little people like myself get rewarded for their efforts to get an outlet to make some money too? I can’t rely on google’s adsense and its “smart-pricing” of ad network. When my site gets repeatedly knocked from a PR4 to a PR0, that pretty much kills me in my marketing efforts.

    tony dee’s last blog post..Comfortable Workout Clothing

  • http://prosperitywriter.com/ Prosperity Writer

    well google is always playing god as far as small webmasters like me are concern

  • http://www.PremierNetClicks.com CSSteve

    I try not to think of corporations as good guy and bad guy. In the end they are what they are. I can define them as ethical and unethical pretty easily though. I won’t expouse all of my opinions on these two corporations, but I do offer you some potential motives for both of them in my blog. While I don’t have anything against google, don’t think for a minute that microsoft couldn’t help keep the search giant in line.

  • http://www.PremierNetClicks.com CSSteve

    Oops. Here is a corrected link to the blog regarding the potential motives behind the microsoft and yahoo merger.

  • http://www.exposedseo.com seo dude

    We are talking about “saving us” even though monopoly is not a good thing for us, consumers. I would rather see a number of search engines rather than one giant made out of yahoo and Google.

  • http://www.evawhite.com Eva White

    i think no one is the ‘bad guy’, they both are playing business. Google being the super power it will be very difficult for any other search engine to take over google.

    Eva White’s last blog post..Celebrity Buzz?.

  • http://www.netage.co.za Web Developer

    Its a predicament, I dont like MSN yet that’s too much power for Google. Whatever happens will happen and we will adapt.

  • http://mp3leben.com Tiffany

    Yeah Eva is right. We cannot say Google is the bad guy or Microsoft is. Both of them have their own business to be the greatest web company…Even Yahoo I believe has this aim too.

  • http://thetoptenme.wordpress.com/2008/09/10/is-our-beloved-google-dead/ Chirag Chamoli

    any given day Google is worse than Microsoft.

    Chirag Chamoli’s last blog post..Google ‘vs? Microsoft, Business As Usual

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/04803976960167716699 Victor Hooper

    Who owns the web is an interesting question that we should all ask. What any of us type should not have any monetary value but it seems to. Google now seems to have its eyes set on the phone, word prosessing, web mail, and other markets. Will Google come out with its own operating system? Will Microsoft tap into the phone industry? What about social networking? Possibily.

    Will Google ever try to take on Apply by say-launching its own iPod? Not likly. Only time will tell. Maybe five years from now some unheard company will spring up and swallow Google.

    Victor Hooper’s last blog post..Google vs Microsoft

  • Patrick

    Wow you’re not biased! And I think it’s very weird for you to call any company as successful as Microsoft “evil”. If it weren’t for them, you wouldn’t be able to write these stupid posts all day and you might have had to get a life!

  • SAHIL YADAV

    what is DIGG.