Marketing Pilgrim's "Research" Channel

Sponsor Marketing Pilgrim's Research Channel today! Get in front of some of the most influential readers in the Internet and social media marketing industry. Contact us today!

Google Caffeine Test Suggests Too Much Emphasis on Real-Time Indexing



Google has gone ahead and done what search marketers could only have previously dreamed about: given us an advance preview of search engine update "Caffeine."

Announced at the Webmaster Central Blog, Caffeine is "a secret project: a next-generation architecture for Google’s web search." Ooh, how exciting! While the official announcement warns not to expect any obvious changes–it claims most of the updates are "under the hood"–Matt Cutts admitted that "some of the search results do change, so we wanted to open up a preview so that power searchers and web developers could give us feedback."

Well, here’s some feedback–garnered on my very first query–Google may have dialed up too much focus on Twitter. Take a look at this comparison:

That’s the normal Google results page. Notice that my Twitter profile sits at #7. Now take a look at Caffeine:

I love using Twitter, but is it really the 2nd most relevant result for a search for my name? Relevant enough that it displays not only my Twitter profile, but that of another "Andy Beal?" I don’t think so. It’s almost as if, in Google’s attempts to include more social media "real time" results, it turned the dial to 11, when 7 would have worked just fine.

Another clue that Caffeine is focused on speed–perhaps at the sacrifice of relevancy–is there appears to be more "Similar" only and less "Cached" results. What’s that you ask? Well, when Google wants to get new results populating in its index, it often does so, even before it fully gets to cache/index the page. A search for the very recently passed away Eunice Kennedy Shriver, reveals twice as many results without a "cache" as the normal Google index. In fact, 3 out of the top 5 results had no cache!

That could be a very good thing–after all, we want the freshest information–but, as you saw from the Twitter example, Google needs to find a way of including "real time" results without letting social media skew its non time-sensitive SERPs.

I’m going to keep digging around. I’m glad that Google’s willing to give us a glimpse of things to come. Of course, the search giant will do a lot of fine tuning before making Caffeine its daily habit (pun intended), but I suspect we’ll see social media playing a big role in Google’s results–and that doesn’t appear to be limited to just very fresh topics.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] tweaks are faster and illustrate the search giant’s focus on technology. Others are focused on real-time indexing of Twitter and SEO. I’m in the camp that can’t find much difference. On topics near and [...]

  2. [...] MEDIA:  Twitter, FaceBook and other social media items seem to be performing better in the [...]

  3. [...] Google’s Caffeine testing ground might contain few changes to the user interface, that’s not stopping the [...]

  4. [...] questions that I am sure will arise if and when Google decide to implement ‘Caffeine’. Andy Beal of Marketing Pilgrim fame has written a piece on the testing he has done and effect that social media has on the [...]

  5. [...] references can be found here: Google’s New Search Index Google Caffeine Tests var addthis_pub="consult"; var addthis_brand = "Outrider Australia"; var addthis_header_color = [...]

  6. [...] Announced at the Webmaster Central Blog, Caffeine is “a secret project: a next-generation architecture for Google’s web search. When Google wants to get new results populating in its index, it often does so, even before it fully gets to cache/index the page. http://www.marketingpilgrim.com/2009/08/google-caffeine-test-suggests-too-much-emphasis-on-real-time… [...]

  7. [...] Google Caffeine Test Suggests Too Much Emphasis on Real-Time IndexingGoogle has gone ahead and done what search marketers could only have previously dreamed about: given us an advance preview …Read More [...]

  8. [...] Monday’s launch of the Google Caffeine sandbox, there have been numerous articles and posts offering ideas on what’s different between “regular Google” and the new [...]

  9. [...] Monday’s launch of the Google Caffeine sandbox, there have been numerous articles and posts offering ideas on what’s different between “regular Google” and the new results in [...]

  10. [...] live engine.  There aren’t many.  A lot of people in the SEO realm have weighed in with their initial thoughts; I thought I’d add my [...]

  11. [...] Google Caffeine Test Suggests Too Much Emphasis on Real-Time Indexing [...]

  12. [...] experts say? “Google Caffeine Test Suggests Too Much Emphasis on Real-Time Indexing” -Andy Beal “…my guess is that it likely does what Google search does, but better. And the [...]

  13. [...] Google Caffeine Test Suggests Too Much Emphasis on Real-Time Indexing [...]

  14. [...] it’s been brought up by Andy Beal that a Social Media SERP result might not always be what you want … …. Google needs to find a way of including [...]

  15. [...] D’après les tests, Caffeine ne présente pas une modification fondamentale des classements des résultats mais une plus grande rapidité dans le traitement des résultats, allant jusqu’au temps réel (source Search Engine Watch) et une survalorisation des résulats issus des media sociaux, notamment de Twitter (test faits par Andy Beal). [...]

  16. [...] Google Caffeine Test Suggests Too Much Emphasis on Real-Time Indexing [...]

  17. [...] Google Caffeine: Google’s New Search Engine Index 2. Google Caffeine Test Suggests Too Much Emphasis on Real-Time Indexing 3. Is Google Caffeine Faster? 4. Google Caffeine Search Index & Algorithm Update 5. Google [...]

  18. [...] more ‘real time’, relevant search results. But this post from Marketing Pilgrim: Google Caffeine Test Suggests too much Emphasis on Real Time Indexing; has suggested that Caffeine is more about speed, perhaps at the expense of [...]

  19. […] Google Caffeine Test Suggests Too Much Emphasis on Real-Time Indexing […]